Pappy John's Original Barbecue

Pappy John's Original Barbecue Barbecue restaurant

Overview

If you're in the mood for mouthwatering barbecue, Pappy John's Original Barbecue in Selmer, Tennessee, is a must-visit. Located at 3597 US-45, this charming diner has become a local favorite, known for its hearty portions, tender meats, and friendly atmosphere. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, this spot promises a memorable dining experience that keeps people coming back for more.

The menu at Pappy John's is packed with all the classics you'd expect from a top-notch barbecue joint. From smoked brisket to pulled pork, the offerings here cater to all kinds of barbecue lovers. One of the standout dishes is their signature ribs, which are perfectly smoked, tender, and slathered in a rich, tangy sauce. The flavors are bold but not overwhelming, letting the meat shine through with every bite.

Another highlight is the pulled pork sandwich, served with a generous helping of coleslaw and a side of crispy fries. The pork is always tender, and the coleslaw adds a creamy crunch that complements the smoky meat perfectly. If you're looking for something a bit heartier, try the combo platter. It features a variety of meats, so you can sample some of everything, including juicy sausage links and flavorful chicken.

For those with a sweet tooth, don't skip out on the dessert options. The homemade pies, like pecan and sweet potato, are a treat to end your meal on a high note. They're made fresh daily, and you can tell that a lot of care goes into making them just right. Pair your meal with a refreshing iced tea or one of their homemade lemonades for a true Southern experience.

What sets Pappy John's Original Barbecue apart from other barbecue spots in the area is the sense of community that fills the air. The staff is always friendly, and many of the patrons are regulars who strike up conversations with anyone who walks through the door. It's not just about the food; it's about feeling like you're part of something special. The cozy, rustic vibe adds to the charm of the place, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a laid-back meal with family or friends.

The restaurant’s location in Selmer is another reason why it stands out. Situated right off US-45, it’s easy to spot and accessible to both locals and travelers. The diner has become a popular pit stop for anyone heading through this part of Tennessee, offering a welcoming space to refuel with a delicious meal before hitting the road again.

In terms of customer reviews, Pappy John's Original Barbecue has earned its place as one of the top-rated dining spots in the area. Many visitors rave about the quality of the food, the friendly service, and the warm, inviting atmosphere. One common piece of feedback is how consistent the food is-whether it's your first visit or your tenth, you can count on getting a great meal every time.

It’s clear that Pappy John’s isn’t just another barbecue restaurant-it’s a place where the food and the people come together to create something truly special. The dedication to quality, combined with the welcoming vibe, makes this diner a standout destination for anyone craving authentic Southern barbecue. Whether you’re a barbecue aficionado or just someone who appreciates a good home-cooked meal, Pappy John’s offers a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.

Good to know

From the business

βœ“ Identifies as women-owned

Service options

βœ“ Outdoor seating βœ“ Kerbside pickup βœ“ Delivery βœ“ Drive-through βœ“ Takeaway βœ“ Dine-in

Highlights

βœ“ Serves local specialty

Popular for

βœ“ Lunch βœ“ Dinner βœ“ Solo dining

Accessibility

βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible car park βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance βœ“ Wheelchair-accessible seating βœ“ Assistive hearing loop

Offerings

βœ“ Comfort food βœ“ Quick bite βœ“ Small plates

Dining options

βœ“ Brunch βœ“ Lunch βœ“ Dinner βœ“ Catering βœ“ Counter service βœ“ Dessert βœ“ Seating βœ“ Table service

Amenities

βœ“ Toilet

Atmosphere

βœ“ Casual βœ“ Cosy βœ“ Quiet βœ“ Trendy

Crowd

βœ“ Family friendly βœ“ Tourists

Planning

βœ“ Accepts reservations

Payments

βœ“ Cheques βœ“ Credit cards βœ“ Debit cards βœ“ NFC mobile payments βœ“ Credit cards

Children

βœ“ Good for kids βœ“ High chairs βœ“ Kids' menu

Parking

βœ“ Free of charge street parking βœ“ Free parking lot βœ“ Parking

Pets

βœ“ Dogs allowed βœ“ Dogs allowed outside

Photos

Location

Reviews

- No ratings yet 457 reviews
Amazing 330
Great 80
Okay 25
Not Great 20
Terrible 29
Tammy Shamlin Hansen

Love the food the sweet tea is perfect. The fried okra is so good I could just order a big plate and be happy! The pulled pork and BBQ sauce is the bomb ! Love the BBQ sauce choices. Wonderful friendly server. Good job!

Ken Julian

The ladies were nice. The food, a pulled pork BBQ plate was served quickly. All the food was good. If I had to pick my least favorite thing it would be the potato salad, Every one makes it different, this was just not to my taste. Overall a good meal.

Troy Flamm

Food was delicious. Small shack but has room and it's comfy. Food was delicious. You know the potato salad is home made when it's dumped outta a sour cream tub. It was delicious. The pork was well seasoned and very moist. It was delicious. It was well wrapped in a to go order. The service was amazing as well. The shack was very clean. Great ladies in there working today. Parking was enough to get my semi in there and on the shoulder so Parking isn't a issue. Go get some great BBQ here it's worth every penny I spent 15.00 dollars.

Jay Pollard

This is a small mom and pop place. The Ribs were fall off the bone good! The staff was exceptional, friendly people. Now it's time for food coma

Alan Hedrick

Purposely passed a lot of BBQ joints to get to Pappy’s!! BBQ is excellent. Servings are on the large side. BBQ sauce is really great. We did the sausage sandwich and took home a BBQ pack for later. BBQ Bologna was EXCELLENT as well. They’re busy with the drive thru - but quick. Not a long wait. Not overly friendly but we came to eat - not socialize.

Dorris Stanfill

Absolutely great BBQ & great customer service experience. The ladies there are absolutely sweet & very respectful. The atmosphere is absolutely stunning. Older country style vibes. BBQ itself I rate 10/10, baked beans 10/10, Cole slaw 10/10, and potato salad I give 0/10. I didn't like the potato salad BUT everyone is different. Next time I think I'll try loaded Nachos.

Robin Kuchenbecker

This place is phenomenal I honestly can't say that enough. We got a mix of everything, chicken, pulled pork sandwiches, loaded fries, ribs etc etc (large family and we REALLY like to eat). It was amazing. The decor was SOOOO cute, the service was great. You can't miss out on this place!

Write a review